Selection Cannot See a Genotype

AP Biology · Unit 7 · Topic 7.2

Selection Cannot See a Genotype

Selection acts on what an organism is, not on what it carries. That one restriction explains why a harmful recessive allele can never quite be driven out, and the model says how much survives.

Learning objective 7.2.A Describe the importance of phenotypic variation in a population, and 7.2.B explain how variation in molecules within cells connects to fitness.

The same allele, the same selection, two kinds of population

Topic 7.1 ran a haploid population, where every individual wears its allele on the outside. Here the identical harmful allele faces the identical selection in a diploid population, where it can hide.

Haploid, after 100 generations—
Diploid, after 100 generations—
Selection against the homozygote—
Cleared from the population?—

Where the copies actually are

Selection can only act on an allele when it shows. Follow the last column down as the allele gets rarer.

Frequency of the alleleCopies in affected homozygotesCopies hidden in carriersShare that is hidden
Why selection slows down exactly as it succeeds

What this means for eliminating a harmful allele

A genetic disease caused by a recessive allele cannot be removed from a population by selection against affected individuals, however severe the condition. At a frequency of one in a thousand, 99.9% of the copies are in healthy carriers who are unaffected and unselected. This is not a limitation of medicine or of time — it is arithmetic, and it is why carrier screening exists and why eugenic programs aimed at eliminating recessive conditions were doomed on their own terms as well as being monstrous.